top of page

We are working on changes to this website.  Login is temporarily unavailable.

Learn More

Painted Portobellos in Puff Pastry

A smoky-sweet and tangy pastry, with a mild to medium spicy heat.

by Deb

(dynamic)

Agaricus bisporus. © Christian Schwarz (CC-BY-NC) (from inaturalist.org, obs. 10379455)

Method

  1. Preheat oven to the puff pastry brand's recommended temperature (or 425°F).

  2. Beat egg lightly with 1 Tbsp. of water to create an egg wash.

  3. Roll out a puff pastry square on a floured surface, large enough so that the ends can be easily folded up over a mushroom cap. (Since portobellos vary in size, you may have to roll out the puff pastry to different sizes. Avoid rolling thinner than 1/8", so you don't crush the butter layers.)

  4. Paint the portobello caps and gills liberally** with the puréed chipotle, and place cap down on the puff pastry.***

  5. Fold the puff pastry ends up so they meet and complete enclose the mushroom cap.

  6. Turn the pastry over and place on a lined baking sheet.

  7. Brush each pastry with egg wash. Optionally, cut a decorative design into the pastry.

  8. Place in oven and bake at the pastry brand's recommended temperature (or 425°F) until pastry is golden.


** Chipotle peppers are dried, smoked red jalapeño chiles. They are usually sold canned in a tangy tomato-and-vinegar adobo sauce, most commonly pureed. Thus, the sauce will have a mild to medium heat. Since you'll be "painting" the mushrooms (not putting normal jalapeños in the pastry), you can adjust amount of sauce to taste.


*** Revision: Newer food safety guidelines recommend avoiding undercooked mushrooms. To address this, either first gently sauté the caps until they soften, or roast the painted caps at 400°F for 15 to 20 minutes. Allow the caps to cool before placing them on the rolled out dough (so they don't melt the fat in the dough). Depending on your puff pastry brand and oven, precooking the mushrooms (and thus evaporating excess moisture) may also help to make your pastry more crisp and flaky.

Recipe contributed:

October

1995

This recipe was adapted from a newly published cookbook, A Cook's Book of Mushrooms by Jack Czarnecki.


Jack is the owner/chef of Joe's Restaurant in Reading, Pennsylvania and The Joel Palmer House in Dayton, Oregon, and at least a second generation fungal forager.


Jack prepared and shared several elegant recipes from his new book at a cooking demo/lunch in Carmel recently. The recipes are geared to exotic mushrooms now available in stores such as Oysters, Chanterelles, Portobellos, etc., though they are certainly adaptable to other wild mushrooms. A bit more sophisticated than the usual mushroom cookbook, this is a great book for the veteran chef and a good introduction to wild mushroom cookery for new foragers who feel confident gathering a few varieties and purchasing the rest.


Happily for us, thanks to FFSC member Phyllis Cole and Athena Reschke, it is currently available in stores, a great holiday gift. Check it out at the next club meeting! Jack will also be speaking at one of our club meetings this year, he's a great chef and very entertaining.


Editor's Note: A Cook's Book of Mushrooms won a James Beard Award in 1996. The original cookbook with 100 recipes is out of print, but it's still available at thrift bookstores. A newer book by Jack Czarnecki, Joe's Book of Mushroom Cookery is also available with over 300 recipes; as well as mushroom-specific cookbooks, Truffle in the Kitchen: A Cook's Guide, and Portobello Cookbook.

Objective:

Side or first course

Total Time:

30 to 60 mins

Yield:

4 servings

Suggested Mushrooms:

  • Porcini (Boletus edulis, Boletus regineus, Boletus rex-veris)
  • Portobello/portabella, champignon, cremini, button (Agaricus bisporus)

Join FFSC or renew your membership to access the rest of this content.

Login as an FFSC member to access the rest of this content.

Ingredients

4 x 5 inch squares of all butter puff pastry dough

4 fresh portobellos* (3 - 5 inches wide caps, no wider)

2 Tbsp. pureed chipotle peppers in adobo**

2 Tbsp. Chinese oyster sauce

1 egg

Water

Flour


Baking sheet (full or half sheet, big enough to fit your mushroom caps with room to spare)

Parchment paper or silicone mat to line the baking sheet


* Jack notes that this can also be made with any of the larger wild mushrooms, and is particularly good with porcini. Due to the spiciness of the chipotle peppers, avoid mild mushrooms such as oysters.

bottom of page