top of page

We are working on changes to this website.  Login is temporarily unavailable.

Learn More

Field observations - the same mushrooms from a lower angle (modified)

News & Stories

/

Field Reports

Matsutake or Amanita? Thank You, Debbie Viess!

Since last year the Albion forays are one of my favorite times of the mushroom season. This season, at the first Albion, I joined Dawn, Drew, Sergiy and Richard to foray for matsutake.

Maria Tanase

Maria Tanase

January 1, 2011

Field observations - the same mushrooms from a lower angle (modified)

Western Matsutake (Tricholoma murrillianum). Photo by Hugh Smith


At the first stop, three feet into the forest, Richard found the first cluster of mushrooms and he called Dawn to come from the car, to pick them. Unfortunately the cluster was a group of Russula and Lactarius, not matsies, and the spot was almost empty.


Sergiy finally got 3 matsutake and I found 2 (one big, ID’d by Richard, and then a button). Back at the cars Dawn, looking at my button, asked how I could be sure that is a matsutake.


At the next spot I found a few more matsutake and then we moved to a chanterelle spot. Having a good Santa Cruz chanterelle spot, I wasn’t too much into picking chanterelles so I started picking hedgehogs. Then I stepped on the Black Trumpets (Craterellus cornucopioides) and in no time my basket was full with blacks, even if it wasn’t their season. I learned later that this location is a known blacks spot by others, but none had thought to check it.


Back at the Field Station I sorted and cleaned the mushrooms, but I still had a doubt about those two matsutakes. I asked Debbie Viess if she would take a look at my first pair of matsutakes and, as always, the answer was “Yes, I’d be glad to”.


I took my first-picked matsutake from the bag and showed it to her. The answer was “yes it is a Matsie”, but when I showed her the second one, even with that button still in my hand, the answer was immediately “now that is a bad Amanita - Amanita silvicola”. Then she and David explained to me, and a few other people around, the differences between matsutakes and Amanita and what to check for. A lesson I will never forget.


Thank you to Debbie and to all FFSC club leaders. The organized forays are the best way to really learn mushrooms, and believe me with an Amanita in your

basket by mistake, the lesson has much more weight.


Learn more about these mushrooms:

Members Only Content

Related Posts

Albion II, 2011 – Great Forays, Fungi and Food

Albion II, 2011 – Great Forays, Fungi and Food

Memories of Matsutake

Memories of Matsutake

Previous Article

All News & Stories

Next Article

bottom of page